African elephants around Victoria Falls travel along familiar routes to avoid hunters and human conflict. A new study found that they use these routes to manage risk across a fragmented landscape of fear.
The study is titled Hunting by humans affects the navigation of two endangered mammals in Brazil and Zimbabwe. It compared elephants around Victoria Falls with capuchin monkeys at Una Biological Nature Reserve in Brazil. Researchers wanted to know whether both species use habitual travel routes to avoid human-influenced areas and traumatic risk events. They collared ten adult elephants around Victoria Falls.
What Is the “Landscape of Fear”?
The findings, published on nature.com, define the “landscape of fear” (LOF) as the perception of risk. This perception forces prey species to keep changing their behaviour.
“Animals may choose habitats with lower potential energy intake and lower perception of risk over those with higher potential energy intake and higher perceived risk, thus trading off food quality for safety,” the report said.
Elephants Rely on Habitual Routes Where Hunting Occurs
The researchers used GIS, primary movement data and remote sensing technology. They found that elephants use habitual routes more often in landscapes where humans hunt.
According to the study, elephants use their LOF to spot risky locations and risky human activities, including trophy hunting. “In Victoria Falls, elephants rely heavily on the habitual route strategy, which likely helps them respond to unpredictable events, like when human hunting poses a threat,” the report said.
The authors describe humans as mobile predators that move through habitats in search of prey. Habitual routes may make elephants more alert to signs of trophy hunting. They may also keep elephants in areas they remember as safe.
Bushes, Grasslands and Towns
Elephants also use habitual routes often when they pass through urban areas. Well-defined street networks probably make navigation easy for them.
In hunting areas, elephants used habitual routes far more often when crossing bushes and open grasslands. “Bushes and grasslands cover large areas within elephant ranges, and encompass many hunting areas around Victoria Falls,” the report added.
In these habitats, safe habitual routes matter more because elephants cannot easily hide from predators. The pattern was stronger where trophy hunting was allowed.
Farmland and Woodland Corridors
Agricultural fields within hunting areas affected how elephants used their routes. Even so, elephants did not avoid the fields altogether. They used remaining patches of woodland to move through these areas, despite the risk of conflict with people.
“In Victoria Falls, it is common to find corridors of woodland surrounded by human activities,” the report said. This fragmentation explains why elephants use habitual routes so heavily in woodlands surrounded by farms. These woodlands give them the cover they need when they cross agricultural land. Valuable food may also outweigh the perceived risk.
The study also found that elephants used habitual routes less often when the routes were long. Trophy hunting areas, woodlands and bushy areas all increased habitual route use around Victoria Falls. “In hunting areas, the elephants had higher numbers of habitual routes through the woodlands, agricultural areas, urban areas, bush lands and grasslands,” the study added.
How Elephants Read Human Threats
The study also showed that male African elephants can sense different levels of threat from humans. They recognise human hunters through smell, sound and sight. These skills let elephants respond to both human and non-human predators.
Blocked Migration Routes in Zimbabwe
Human settlements and activities have blocked or restricted elephant migration routes. This has reduced the elephants’ ability to disperse. As a result, human-wildlife conflict has become more frequent and more severe in parts of Zimbabwe.
Elephants in the Middle Zambezi Valley in the north and the south-eastern Lowveld still cannot cross huge minefields. The colonial government laid these minefields to stop freedom fighters from infiltrating from Zambia and Mozambique during Zimbabwe’s war of liberation.
Reporting based on original coverage by The Standard.